An Open Letter To The Cast Of Anastasia on Broadway.

It’s been said that Broadway is a place where dreams are born, but I have to disagree.

Having walked the hollowed sidewalks of this magical place on two occasions now, I believe Broadway is a place where dreams are shared, and each time those dreams grow even more glorious and complex.

A simple street sign with immeasurable power over millions of dreamers.


On Wednesday, August the thirtieth I arose from my far-too-brief slumber to hop in a limousine (yes, one can actually hop into a limousine, just watch you head) with my daughter and as we made our way through the dark Canadian night of Niagara Falls to the Toronto airport to board a plane bound for New Jersey’s Newark airport (insert Jersey joke here) I had to ask myself:

“Why in the world did I drag myself out of bed after working a crazy shift the night before just to visit Broadway for one day? Am I nuts?”

Oh, did I mention my daughter and I were flying into Newark at ten in the morning, hitting Times Square/Broadway for the day and then flying back to Canada at nine in the evening?

At this point you’re either thinking one of two things: One) “You really are nuts, Hook!” or Two) “Aw, you’re such a great dad, Hook!”

Incidentally, both thoughts are perfectly acceptable and valid.

The truth is, my daughter has been mercilessly bullied, ignored, marginalized and made to feel she has no friends for most of her eighteen years on this planet. She suffers from a medical condition called interstitial cystitis that only affects 2% of females under the age of forty and spends most of her nights sitting up in bed waiting for her pain to subside so she can get some sleep. In the meantime she she surfs the interweb and reads about one thing and one thing only…

Broadway, baby. It’s all about Broadway. Sarah’s world revolves around the glorious dreams that unfold on various stage at Broadway’s theatres.

And that, my friends, is why I sacrificed precious hours of sleep to stand in various lines at two airports in two countries before standing in a final line outside the Broadhurst Theatre. Needless to say, my daughter didn’t stand in any lines… she floated above them.

No, my child isn’t a witch, she was just metaphorically floating on air. Canadians are weird, but we’re not that weird.

It should also be noted that Sarah has become a strong, independent young woman with a gifted for the written word. Indeed, my daughter has become the sort of scribe I wish to emulate if and when I ever grow up. I’d be proud to know Sarah even if she wasn’t my child.



Ironically, Sarah’s elation reached a fever pitch before the curtain rose on that afternoon’s matinee of Anastasia. A form brushed past her back as we stood in line and a voice rang out, “Excuse me.” This figure, unknown to virtually every theatergoer save for my child entered the Broadhurst through the stage door and disappeared immediately. Sarah began to tremble and struggled to form a coherent thought, to say nothing of uttering a single sentence.

“Did you see… that was… I can’t believe… that was (voice lowering) John Bolton!”

And so it began.

We made our way into the Broadhurst, purchased a programme, took our seats and soaked in the atmosphere. It’s difficult to describe the energy one feels before a dream comes to life but luckily that power still resonates in Sarah’s eyes and so I can spend the rest of my life trying.


It would take a more adept scribe than myself to do justice to the performances of John Bolton, Derek Klena and company but I will say this: every cast member of Anastasia, from a seemingly-inconspicuous Royal guard to an expat Russian aristocrat drinking their sorrows away in Paris gives 110%. They believe in every note. They open their heart with every gesture. And the audience can feel it and truly is a part of the journey.

Not to play favorites, but I cannot say enough about Anya/Anastasia herself, Christy Altomare. In my daughter’s own words:

“She struggled for years just to get noticed but she never gave up!  She’s one of us and you can see it in every performance!  I hope she never realizes how good she is!”

The same can be said for every cast member; none of them appear to realize just how blessed they are to be the messengers of such a beautiful dream. Anastasia is about the enduring bonds of family, bonds that can survive any act of violence regardless of how horrific they may be. Anastasia is about the often conflicting love for one’s country and above all, it is about the struggle to recognize and accept one’s identity.

Heady issues for a “simple musical” it’s true, but Anastasia speaks to every soul who is fortunate enough to see it. Love. Honor. Sacrifice. Even some of the most hilarious onstage kissing you’ve ever seen, all of these factor into the journey that is Anastasia. And the production values? Well, they’re a cut above, kids.

From the moment you sit down you’re wowed by a curtain that features projected snow cascading across its surface.

Beat that, Hamilton.

(My kid’s going to kill me for that but it was totally worth it.)


My Broadway moment.  And not coincidentally, the exact moment all the lights exploded… 


But back to the production values: A monolithic screen sits behind the actors and transforms you from a doomed St. Petersburg ballroom to a European railway to a Parisian street instantaneously. The behind-the-scenes artists of Anastasia are the true unsung heroes of Broadway. And speaking of unsung heroes…

There was a slight casting issue that gave Sarah cause for concern. The “regular” Gleb, Ramin Karimloo, didn’t appear at our performance, a fact that did not go over well at first. “He’s Canadian! How often does one of us get to be here?” However, when Ramin’s “replacement”, Wes Hart, took the stage… he did not win her over.

But by his second performance she was hooked, pardon the pun.

Indeed, I found myself completely overwhelmed by Anastasia. I recently lost a dear friend to suicide and so I was apprehensive about watching an entire family, fictional or not, be wiped from existence.

But Anastasia captured my heart and left me with a deeper appreciation for my daughter’s dreams and passions. And for that, my new friends, I thank you all.

“We’re headed for the big time… The Hook’s blog!”


One more thing, as the curtain rose and we made our way back to the New York crowds the next phase of our journey began. Waiting for autographs and pics by the stage door is a Broadway tradition, one that Sarah discovered when we saw Hamilton in April. We were honored to take part in that tradition once more, especially when we realized all of Anastasia’s principles would be joining us.

Sarah was too starstruck to articulate her feelings to Mary Beth Peil, John Bolton, Derek Klena, Nicole Scimeca and company, but she found the courage to tell Christy Altomare that she was “the best Anya they could have ever found”.

Tears welled in Christy’s eyes. Tears welled in Sarah’s eyes. I was all cried out from the performance.

In closing, Anastasiacs (I just made that up!) I can never thank you enough for lighting a fire in my daughter’s memory that time will never be able to extinguish. My daughter and I now have two Broadway shows under our belt (Hamilton in April was more than Sarah could ever have imagined and so Anastasia was an unbelievable bonus) and with any luck we’ll be able to sell some more organs (not our own of course) and make our way back to New York from Niagara Falls again soon.

See you in the lobby and on the web, friends…

About The Hook

Husband. Father. Bellman. Author of The Bellman Chronicles. Reader of comic books and observer and chronicler of the human condition. And to my wife's eternal dismay, a mere mortal and non-vampire. I'm often told I look like your uncle, cousin, etc. If I wore a hat, I'd hang it on a hat rack in my home in Niagara Falls, Canada. You can call me The Hook, everyone else does.
This entry was posted in Hotel Life and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

28 Responses to An Open Letter To The Cast Of Anastasia on Broadway.

  1. A beautiful post, Hook. That trip had to have been worth every organ you could sell. Thanks for sharing this wonderful experience.

  2. Marion Hardy says:

    Now you are making me cry Hook. You ARE a great dad with an absolute darling of a daughter. I love theatre and going toBroadway when I was about Sarah’s age awakened my love of the arts.❌🔴

  3. davidprosser says:

    You’re an amazing Dad Robert but to hear you talk it’s understandable since your daughter deserves no less. Given that you’re a talented blogger too I’ve decided to give up the idea of ever competing so I can save face.

    I’m glad you enjoyed your trip and hope you caught up on the sleep.

    • The Hook says:

      It’s not about competition, David; each of us has our journey to travel.
      I often feel like I’m eating the dust of tons of bloggers out there.
      You know I haven’t realized all my dreams but I’ll never stop dreaming and neither should you.

  4. nbratscott says:

    I, too, had to wipe my eyes before commenting. I know you’re used to smart-ass comments from me, but you’ve moved me today.

    I know the bell desk is not providing a lot of disposable income these days, and you are a proud man….but I think you should start a GO FUND ME page for SARAH’S BROADWAY EXPERIENCE.

    I would love to donate a few bucks to help. (18yrs with you…she deserves a break) I couldn’t help myself!!! You might even have enough to take Mrs. Hook!!!

  5. Austin says:

    How much would it have cost to take the limo all the way to Broadway? That would’ve been some entrance. 🙂

  6. umashankar says:

    It is not often that I read posts that melt my heart. Thank you for the treat, Hook! My blessings to Sarah.

  7. Becky says:

    This was so lovely to read. What an incredible experience to share with your daughter! You truly are a great dad, Hook!

  8. My first career was the theatre and I miss NYC like a lover (professional theatre even more so), so I read this post with my heart in my mouth!

    Tell your sweet daughter that it is fans like her that keeps folks like the ones she saw on stage keepin’ on keepin’ ON — and that everyone knows they’re “good” in NYC (you don’t last a month if you are not – and you don’t even try it if you don’t think you have a shot). It still is WONDERFUL to hear that others think so as well, however, so tell her never to hold back with those assertions. They’ll only work harder to be even better.

    Since my 9/1 monthly Awareness post disclosed that September is Suicide Prevention Awareness Month (among others), I must add how sad I was to read that you recently lost a friend to it. I am so sorry for your loss.
    (Madelyn Griffith-Haynie – ADDandSoMuchMORE dot com)
    ADD/EFD Coach Training Field founder; ADD Coaching co-founder
    “It takes a village to transform a world!”

    • The Hook says:

      Rockin’ Ronnie as he was known at the hotel, was a fellow bellman and my brother in spirit. Watching him slowly slip away still haunts me and always will.
      Thank you for being here, MGH.

      • It is a heartbreak – and there is so little we can actually DO for them but let them know they will be missed. There is nothing I can say to you that won’t sound specious – healing will take the time it takes to work through the grief. I wish you peace.

  9. That’s a charming tale, Hook. Yes you’re nuts. But hey! I like stories about people who /have a strong streak of obsessive, and b/ write. I read this the day after I got news I’d had yet another short accepted for publication. Your description of your daughter’s abilities struck a chord

  10. I love New York and would happily spend a day on Broadway and Time Square. I’ve done it and although I prefer spending a few days, I would do it again! It’s wonderful to hear how the magic envelopes you and your daughter on these adventures. You are an amazing, Dad! Of course I’d have to say that Sarah is a pretty amazing daughter, as well!

  11. All the world’s a stage…sometimes we just need brighter lights and raised steps to notice
    BIg things are at work here, Hook – hold on (and be ready to let go when she’s ready)

    • The Hook says:

      I doubt I’ll ever be ready for that, but I think you’re right; my daughter is desperately trying to find herself right now.
      It hasn’t been easy but she’ll get there. Broadway is definitely in her future in some way, shape or form.

  12. StillWaters says:

    Well done, Mr. Hook. Glad you and your daughter had such a grand time.

  13. curvyroads says:

    Two months late, but this post made me cry tears of happiness for you both! You are a great Dad, Robert! 😍

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s